ETHERLive delivers real-time price and volume data across 16+ exchanges to users in a clear and easy-to-understand package. Users can get up-to-the-second updates for each exchange/currency pair, as well as aggregated market averages for each exchange, currency, and the market as a whole. It also provides a global converted average of all the currency pairs monitored by ETHNews, converted to USD.


24hr ---

The Basics

Learn the basics of Ethereum and various cryptocurrency technologies

Learn More

What is Ethereum?

Understand the underlying principles of the Ethereum Platform

Learn More

The Blockchain

Discover the revolutionizing technology known as the blockchain

Learn More

Press Release

Submit a press release for consideration on ETHNews

Submit Press

Story / Dapp

Submit a story or DAPP to be considered for publication on ETHNews.

Submit Story


Submit "Ethereum Explainer" content for consideration to be featured on ETHNews

Submit Topic
ETHNews Logo
Ether Price Analysis
Contact Us

Malta Financial Services Authority Seeks Ecosystem Feedback On DLT Asset Classification




The Maltese Financial Services Authority has published an analysis of how digital assets that are maintained on distributed ledgers are defined under current financial legislation. A new Financial Instrument Test could help both lawmakers and DLT innovators alike determine how digital assets should be classified.

On April 13, the Maltese government continued to build upon its growing crypto-progressive reputation with the release of the Consultation Paper on the Financial Instrument Test, a research report outlining Malta's vision for classifying digital assets that are tracked via distributed ledger technologies (DLTs).  

The 44-page document has three objectives:

  1. Map how definitions for digital assets on distributed ledgers are generally obscured under current regulatory frameworks;
  2. Reaffirm how the Financial Instrument Test can clarify regulatory ambiguity via updated classification standards; and
  3. Prompt "feedback" from the DLT community regarding related ecosystem concerns.

The Old

Building off of its November 2017 Discussion Paper on Initial Coin Offerings, Virtual Currencies and Related Service Providers, the MFSA's most recent report analyzes how the European Union's overarching Market's in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID) defines financial instruments and, more importantly, if those definitions carry implications for DLT assets like virtual currencies.

In addition to evaluating the underlying methodology of the Financial Instrument Test, the MFSA is seeking to discover whether a given DLT asset "is encompassed under (i) the existing EU legislation and corresponding national legislation, (ii) the proposed Virtual Financial Assets Act (VFAA) or (iii) is otherwise exempt."

Industry feedback will be accepted and reviewed on a rolling basis until May 4, 2018, at which point the MSFA will begin establishing a "final version" of the test.

The New

The Financial Instrument Test is likely to be administered in two parts, which will be comprised of 12 checklists for classification. The report states that this process could eventually utilize an "external reviewer."

The first stage would evaluate whether that particular asset qualifies as a Virtual Token (VT) or "utility token," as it is more commonly referred to. The proposed definition for a VT under the VFAA is "a form of digital medium recordation that has no utility, value or application outside of the DLT platform on which it was issued and that cannot be exchanged for funds on such platform or with the issuer of such DLT asset."

If it is not concluded that the asset is a VT, "the second stage would determine whether the DLT asset would qualify as a financial instrument under Section C of Annex 1 in the MiFID," which establishes definitions for financial instruments like transferable securities, money market instruments, and units of collective investment undertakings, among others.

If the second stage also fails to define the asset, then it "would qualify as a Virtual Financial Asset (VFA) under the aforementioned VFAA." The MFSA is hoping that the Financial Instrument Test can become a mandatory requirement under the proposed VFAA, making it applicable to digital asset exchanges and investment intermediaries. The new regulatory stipulations would also apply to "non-licensed persons" who are providing services or performing activities related to DLT assets "in or from within Malta."

The Now

The initiative highlights the incredibly complex task modern financial regulators have found themselves in when trying to classify DLT assets, and introduces the Financial Instrument Test as a stop-gap measure for this peculiar moment in monetary regulation.

It's unclear how long this new test would be useful for, in the ever-changing crypto regulations landscape. However, like the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) Howey Test in the United States, the MFSA's Financial Instrument test could greatly aid regulators as they find a more permanent solution for classifying DLT assets.   

Parties interested in providing feedback to MFSA regarding the Financial Instrument Test or related concerns are encouraged to respond though MFSA's dedicated response website. Per the MFSA consultation paper, questions about the MFSA document itself should be directed to

Jordan Daniell

Jordan Daniell has a passion for techno-social developments and cultural evolution. In his spare time, he enjoys astronomy, playing the bagpipes, and exploring southern California on foot. Jordan holds value in Ether.

ETHNews is committed to its Editorial Policy

Like what you read? Follow us on Twitter @ETHNews_ to receive the latest MFSA, Malta or other Ethereum cryptocurrencies and tokens news.