ETHERLive
ETHERLive delivers real-time price and volume data across 16+ exchanges to users in a clear and easy-to-understand package. Users can get up-to-the-second updates for each exchange/currency pair, as well as aggregated market averages for each exchange, currency, and the market as a whole. It also provides a global converted average of all the currency pairs monitored by ETHNews, converted to USD.

---

24hr ---
--%
Monday Jun 25th 2018
RESOURCES

The Basics

Learn the basics of Ethereum and various cryptocurrency technologies

Learn More

What is Ethereum?

Understand the underlying principles of the Ethereum Platform

Learn More

The Blockchain

Discover the revolutionizing technology known as the blockchain

Learn More
SUBMIT

Press Release

Submit a press release for consideration on ETHNews

Submit Press

Story / Dapp

Submit a story or DAPP to be considered for publication on ETHNews.

Submit Story

Explanation

Submit "Ethereum Explainer" content for consideration to be featured on ETHNews

Submit Topic
ETHNews Logo
---
--%
Home
News
Etherlive
Ether Price Analysis
Resources
Contact Us

Court Allows Customer To Challenge IRS Summons On Coinbase

By

Media

Team

WriterETHNews.com

Update on the IRS Summons on Coinbase – Court Grants Motion to Intervene by John Doe 4.

On July 18, 2017, the Court permitted a Coinbase customer, identified as John Doe 4, to intervene in a proceeding filed by the federal government to enforce an IRS summons issued upon Coinbase. 

On June 29, the Court heard oral arguments on the motion to intervene made by two Coinbase customers, John Does 1 and 2.  On July 6, the Government narrowed the scope of the IRS summons to only Coinbase users with at least $20,000 in any one type of transaction (buying, selling, sending, or receiving) in any single year between 2013 and 2015.  Due to the Government’s decision, the records of John Does 1 and 2 were no longer covered by the IRS summons.  Thus, the Court permitted another customer, John Doe 4, whose records fall within the scope of the narrowed summons, to substitute into the proceeding for John Does 1 and 2.

In today’s ruling, the Court found that John Doe 4 made a sufficient showing of an abuse of process to support intervention as of right. Notably, the Court said:

“The IRS offers no explanation as to how the IRS can legitimately use most of these millions of records on hundreds of thousands of users; instead, it claims that as long as it has submitted a declaration from an IRS agent that the IRS ‘is conducting an investigation to determine the identity and correct federal income tax liabilities of United States persons who conducted transactions in a virtual currency during 2013-2015’ the Court must find that the Summons does not involve an abuse of process. It contends that ‘there seems to be a substantial gap between the number of people transacting in virtual currency (for which tax consequences might attach) and those that are reporting such transactions.’ (Dkt. No. 28 at 13.) But that argument proves too much. Under that reasoning the IRS could request bank records for every United States customer from every bank branch in the United States because it is well known that tax liabilities in general are under reported and such records might turn up tax liabilities.”

Ultimately, the Court found that John Doe 4 satisfied the requirements for intervention as of right, and permissive intervention.  The Court also permitted John Doe 4 to proceed anonymously. 

John Does 1, 2, and 4 are represented by Berns Weiss LLP, which has been challenging the IRS summons on Coinbase since it was issued last November. Less than two weeks ago, Lee A. Weiss, a partner at Berns Weiss, told ETHNews that his office was committed to fighting for Coinbase users’ rights and opposing the Government’s attempt to enforce the summons on Coinbase.

“We still firmly believe that this is an improper use of the IRS John Doe summons procedure. Therefore, our clients will continue to challenge the Government’s petition to enforce the IRS summons.”

According to another Court order, John Doe’s response (as well as Coinbase’s response) to the Government’s Petition to Enforce the IRS summons is due on July 27.

Jeffrey Berns is the Managing Partner of Berns Weiss LLP and is also CEO of Berns Inc, parent company to ETHNews.

Media Team

The media team is the collaborating entirety of the writing staff at ETHNews

ETHNews is committed to its Editorial Policy

Like what you read? Follow us on Twitter @ETHNews_ to receive the latest Coinbase, Internal Revenue Service or other Ethereum law and legislation news.